Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?

deviantART

 
:iconandrewk:

*andrewk

Now doing commissions!
ProfileGalleryPrintsFavesJournal

The School of Rock review

Tue Jul 13, 2004, 1:19 PM
:painter:
-next Norm & Cory
-Untitled issue
-RPG designs for koalakitty23's Tandem website

-

Black and White make a good team. Screenwriter Eric White’s credits include Orange County and The Good Girl, and when writing and appearing in the former, he must’ve found a good partnership with Jack Black, who appeared as a lazy slob. Now, they share writing and screen time in The School of Rock, and once again, the preview succeeds in making it sound dumber than it actually is.

The plot does sound like the standard comedy-of-errors that many comedies try to emulate these days, usually with bad results. A screenplay that thrives on incongruity is always on the edge of nonsense, and the audience will dismiss it no matter how outrageous a comedy it is, because we don’t believe it would happen in the first place. I’m not saying that a guy like Dewey (Black) who fakes his own identity for money to substitute a fifth-grade class in an expensive, conservative private school to teach them rock n’ roll CAN happen, but the film manages to be believable! While remaining to be light-hearted and exciting, the film stops at nothing to express serious matters on what you should expose your kids to. It takes the comedy “seriously”. In one scene, one of the students strays away from the group on a field trip to a theater, winds up hanging out with smoking rock musicians, to which Dewey instantly retrieves him and… says the RIGHT thing to get the kid to listen! This is surprising, since earlier, we see him getting yelled at by his roommate (White) about overdue rent, and replying, “But I’ve been mooching off you for months!”

Thus, what results is what is debatably Black’s best role yet. Black is one of the best reasons this film succeeds, because he IS Dewey, and Dewey IS Black! Rock n’ roll is his life, so much that he’s grown up to become almost a personification of the comic wildness of it, and so it is Dewey’s. I could tell a lot of the longer shots of him in front of the classroom were improvised! And those that weren’t improvised were acted so well that I was convinced enough. Even the child stars, who all have their own personalities, and aren’t bread-and-butter cutsies, all play their roles naturally. Dewey, who vows to his former rock partners that he’ll form his own group, expresses it as a “school project” to the kids, and once he discovers they can play, and play WELL, he shifts into teacher mode like a bolt of lightning and soon spends so much time with them that you begin to wonder where their REAL teacher is all this time! He manages to assign all of them roles, not only as musicians, but also as a manager, back-up girls, lighting effect supervisors, researchers and designers. He even goes so far as to put aside a time slot in the day to give them a course on the history of rock, and THAT’S the point when I think, God! This guy really MEANS it!

Of course, there is also Joan Cusack, who plays the principal of the school, and she’s an inspired, and unexpected, choice for the role of the serious disciplinarian who would cause Dewey’s end doing if she ever discovers he’s not doing his job right! A lot of plot holes would’ve arose in scenes relating to her character (wouldn’t she have overheard the ruckus coming from behind the classroom walls EARLIER in the film?!), but we get the point that she’s a person who is not always on her toes, and we empathize completely with her devotion to the school and the kids.

The ending IS predictable, but a lot of factors play so well that we just dismiss it. The kids’ song that they’ve been rehearsing all this time for is performed and lo and behold, it really IS good, and so, we don’t just watch as the other groups compliment them on their song- we understand them. This plot would only make this film a hit if it were under control by Black and White, and like My Big Fat Greek Wedding, or Bend it Like Beckham, this is a family film that reaches to the adults as well as the kids.

-

***UPDATE***
The computer having problems WOULD’VE been used until Jake takes it IF something never happened to the computer coding- the computer won’t even let me reach the desktop, and so, it might as well not be on at all! The software I use to update my website is on that computer and that one ONLY. So the news about the strips, and anything else, will have to wait to be written there until the computer is fixed as well.

-“I will try to get the word out as much as possible when it's out, but I know there are those of you who are not able to buy it for your own reasons. As such, I was thinking of doing a series of daily strip formats (though, they won't be daily, because I am not that skilled yet), of the same Untitled characters! THis will give you a feeling for the different personalities, themes and situations in the story, allow for some jokes that did not make it in the book, get people excited about buying the book in a different way, and lastly, so those less fortunate don't feel left out.”

-

:spotlight-right: UNTITLED COMIC UPDATE! 7/12/04 :spotlight-left:

-30/40 pages done!
-3/5 extra pages (ads for other people)
-0/1 Cover art

Pretty much all of the story is written now.

-

:spotlight-left: RAYFIC UPDATE! 6/3/04 :spotlight-right:

Should continue to work on Chapter 7. This is starting to be the hardest chapter in the story to write yet!

-

:+devwatch: :+favlove:
ARTIST FRIENDS- ashkeryne bosstones22 cheetahtigerwolfctw countessrazoff janus-zeal kiwifluff lawz-laura madelief mazarin rayfan suicidalcow tarkheki vert-is-ninja

DEVIANT FRIENDS-
abigailryder ailil alaskanbullworm aleron andrewdickman angelstar alphaleo14 bilious dalspots delya dipstikk dogote evilord187 hulamonkie inaam07 kaida kamicheetah koalakitty23 lhhog lionessb lokidjinn louvegarou makani moodyblues mumbojumbo nanashi oedalis ox-of-ice pearlzu queensimia raygirl raysen raystraz rexrock69 rickchick sandora seismic-saffya shiprat spiritwolf77 spunkywulf stonedrabbit tigrin trp86 tvskyle y2jenn

LURKERS-
-seed- aiwa lordakiyama alienfirst allaze andi2003 angelidollinda16 angelsunbomb arcoiris aspera atg astrima athenatt aun61 avencri bandanagirl bara-chan black-nova blindsided2 cat-hicks chalosan cheeks-74 cheesecake cheriestar cl0pin crazy-ray chryseevampu daheroes darkangelx darkburraki darkmane dedredhed dingoroo dreamspirit dyemooch dynamicsketch eiferet erithe espers faeriechild falia fibralo firekitty gardian-ruka gmc9987 gndagnor goblinqueeen gryllus hamorhage hellcorpceo himizu iduck jessetoon jidane jill-calico johnnyelectric jorick kheleksul kimikana kitty-chan koolbeans19 kragen kumanoonna kyoht ladysilverhawk leelakin littlemilie nefgoddess lastscionz localady18 madrob marsw mikemedia ming-a-ling mort-rainey mrneilesq muhunkey mystic-falcon nikori nosseren outerglow ozyoxy questionstar phoenixst pirate-trish pran-man princess-bubblie rajal-tikana ray3885 raymanfan raymangirl rayraider ritam rooo rugdog safiremaria sami-lioness samycat sashamya scottishhammer senorrandom shandy shiirumai silverbobcat sneakerfox snowysmt stickdevil stopitall2003 svarta-perlan teaselbone tekweapons terrkall theknocker theoddone thweatted timshinn73 tsunami-ryuu twinsister ursulav usaribo vaporotem yamita y2hecate zakukun zizzy

-

Clubs I'm in are rfc futurama-forever calvin-hobbes strongbadia color-me-club shrekfans starfieldcreations-c disney-club

Devious Comments

love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconjessetoon:
woo! *claps* great review!

"you're a fat loser with body odour." *snorts and laughs* that was funny. and yeah, i agree with you that this is one of best (if not, THE best) roles jack black has played. he made the character believable, while still entertaining and funny at the same time.

but yeah, your reviews are great. i like how you think.

--
Jesus is coming... look busy.
:icondedredhed:
*coughcostumeflubscough*

--
Undefined, unusual, unrestrained.
non-conformist:not conforming to some norm or socially approved pattern of behavior or thought.
:iconrayfan:
That movie must have been something special to get such an extensive review! I read somewhere that it was good, maybe I'll check it out.

--
Too much not enough sleep. :O_o:
:iconraffle:
Excellent review! I agree with every word :D I loved that movie.
:iconkumanoonna:
Great review! Now I REALLY wanna see the movie!

:)
:iconox-of-ice:
I WANNA SEE ET. O0O

--
"DIS WILL KOM IN HANDI" - *repay
:iconrexrock69:
It's just Fame with rock guitars and American humor -__- Not interested. Nice writeup though.
:iconraystraz:
yay, more movie critic, and to prove I am not being sarcastic.....
NORM WEARS THE COOOLEST GLASSES!!!!!!!
Well, It shut me up....

more randomness coming to a theater near where you live :I

--
you may not know it yet, but I'm the reason your here...
:iconj9y:
It was an awesome movie and one of Jack Black's better roles...

--
"Where are ya, you spongy, yellow, delicious bastards!"-Tallahassee: patron saint of the Crazy Awesome.

Why would some people think today's dubbing of anime is poorly done? 

21%
35 deviants said Because they know they can do better.
19%
32 deviants said They do?
18%
30 deviants said Nothing matches the shows' native language. It applies to all shows and any attempts to prove otherwise. Period.
13%
22 deviants said If you loved a show in your language and suddenly heard it dubbed in another language, wouldn't you feel betrayed?
13%
21 deviants said Other reason (please state).
8%
14 deviants said Because of short-sightedness.
6%
10 deviants said Because it's disrespectful to another language that further exemplifies how much we've grown out of touch with the world.
1%
1 deviant said What is 'dub'?

Site Map